IGN posted the first review of Brothers in Arms for the PC and scored a 9.1
"I had said in the Xbox review of Brothers in Arms that it was easily the best World War 2 game on the system. Now, two weeks later, we've had a chance to take a look at the PC version of the game. The content and overall quality are exactly the same on both systems, making Brothers in Arms an excellent game no matter which platform you choose. "